An ongoing dialogue on HIV/AIDS, infectious diseases,
November 5th, 2011
A Mysteriosis about Listeriosis
For obvious reasons, listeriosis has been much in the news recently. The latest information from CDC on the Colorado cantaloupe outbreak cites 139 cases and 29 deaths.
The recent outbreak aside, however, actual cases of listeriosis are pretty rare. We easily could go months in our hospital without seeing a single case, and we have the largest obstetrical service in New England.
Which brings me to the mystery part: Why is medical student knowledge about listeria so high?
I meet with the medical students to review basics of antibiotics at the beginning of every rotation. Depending on the time of year and the number of prior clinical rotations they’ve done, they have variable amounts of ID knowledge before they get here.
But all of them know about listeria. And they know a lot about it.
- Causative organism? (Listeria monocytogenes — check)
- Dietary risk factors? (deli meats, soft cheeses, now cantaloupes — check)
- Population at risk? (pregnant women, transplant patients, and the elderly — check)
- Clinical manifestations? (meningitis, sepsis, gastroenteritis — check)
- Antibiotic of choice? (ampicillin — check)
They seem to know way more about listeria than they do about far more common infections, such as Strep pneumoniae or Epstein-Barr virus.
It’s the oddest thing. Any proposed explanations for this remarkable expertise would be most welcome.
6 Responses to “A Mysteriosis about Listeriosis”
Paul E. Sax, MD
Contributing Editor
NEJM Journal Watch
Infectious Diseases
Biography | Disclosures | Summaries
Learn more about HIV and ID Observations.
NEJM Journal Watch — Recent Infectious Disease Articles- Rifampin and Gentamicin for Staphylococcal Prosthetic Valve Endocarditis: Strictly Necessary?
- Gauging Risk for Liver Cancer: Hepatitis B Viral Load Might Be a Clue
- A Fungus New to New York City
- Predicting the Need to Resume Treatment When Managing Mycobacterium avium Complex
- Observations from ID and Beyond: Some ID Things to Be Grateful for This Holiday Season — 2024 Edition
For starters, look back to the board exams of the last two decades. There has been a Listeria question on every board exam I’ve ever taken. It’s also been in every board review book I’ve seen (obviously with good reason). If nothing else, we’ve taught our med students to be good test takers.
Perhaps we should also look at the knowledge of the average attending physician. Feel comfortable discussing Listeria on rounds? Well, its been part of pimping lore for a generation….so, Check. Feel comfortable discussing the epidemiology, manifestations, and interpretation of the test of choice for EBV……or the impact on S. pneumo sensitivity patterns on the treatment of meningitis?……Hmm, maybe not so much. That’s when I get a sidebar consult from said attending. Bottom line, we can’t teach what we don’t know. [And to be fair, there’s a wide swath of non-ID subjects I avoid during rounds….]
The same reason that everyone remembers scorpions cause pancreatitis but doesn’t remember drugs. Everyone loves a fascinoma.
I guess it’s because:
– many medschool teachers fail to balance topics by their clinical relevance.
– so do medical textbooks.
– so do, of course, popular media/mass media.
– and a combination of these: it might be more fascinating to go through 500 words of listeriosis – which has been on the news – than go through 50 pages of stroke.
regards,
a.
Jc is exactly right. People dont ask us the easy or common questions often, but you get points for pulling zebras out of your hat. I just took step 1, and I can go on at length about Charcot Marie tooth disease. Please don’t ask me to handle hypertension; I haven’t had my family medicine rotation yet.
Dear UNC MS3 (and others),
Thanks for the MS perspective. Makes sense.
Love that image!
Paul
It is nice to know that pulling zebras out of hats is appreciated more than knowing how to treat hypertension & Strep pneumoniae by medical schools all over the world!