An ongoing dialogue on HIV/AIDS, infectious diseases,
May 12th, 2013
FDA: Fecal Transplants Need Investigational New Drug Application
Gastroenterologists, ID doctors, C diff-sufferers, and microbiome-obsessed humanoids everywhere were treated to this surprising news recently — a decision by the FDA about fecal microbiota transplantation (FMT). From an email sent by the IDSA:
Because fecal microbiota transplantation (FMT) is not approved for any therapeutic purposes, an investigational new drug (IND) application is needed for the use of FMT to treat any disease including C. difficile infection.
More information is on the American Gastroenterological Association site here. This FDA decision was confirmed at a public workshop May 2-3 — “sold out” I’ve been told by one attendee — a meeting which included many interested clinicians and researchers. The FDA plans to hold internal discussions to further refine the regulatory issues surrounding FMT.
I certainly understand the perspective of the FDA, which must consider patient safety as its top priority. But the immediate practical effect of this decision is that getting FMT to the patients who need it — those with recurrent C diff — will now be much more difficult.
And the FDA decision underscores a profound irony in regulatory protocols in our country. A person struggling with C diff can walk into any pharmacy, Whole Foods, Trader Joe’s, GNC, etc, and spend a small fortune on various probiotics, the efficacy of which is marginal at best.
Yet to get FMT, a procedure that has demonstrated quite remarkable efficacy in multiple studies — including this prospective randomized controlled trial — that same patient will need his or her clinician to file an “emergency use” IND application, which is no easy task.
Let’s hope these FDA “internal discussions” proceed expediently. Otherwise, maybe clinicians doing FMT should just start calling it a “supplement.”
11 Responses to “FDA: Fecal Transplants Need Investigational New Drug Application”
Paul E. Sax, MD
Contributing Editor
NEJM Journal Watch
Infectious Diseases
Biography | Disclosures | Summaries
Learn more about HIV and ID Observations.
NEJM Journal Watch — Recent Infectious Disease Articles- Sulopenem Etzadroxil plus Probenecid (Orlynvah) for Uncomplicated Urinary Tract Infections
- Radiolabeled p-Aminobenzoic Acid as a Marker to Detect Bacterial Endocarditis
- Clostridioides difficile Vaccines: Promising Contenders
- Observations from ID and Beyond: Marking a Social Media Mass Migration — Until the Next One
- Incidence of Autoimmune Diseases Involving the Skin, After Acute COVID-19
This may cause our neighbor to DIE! Sceduled for next week with non-rufundable reservations, etc.
Pretty stupid FDA.
I can only hope that therapeutic use of feces doesn’t suffer the same fate as colchicine.
If only the FDA required this rigorous nonsense for other “feces” they’ve readily approved. e.g. donepezil 23 mg
Actually it’s great idea to re-frame FMT as supplement and or offer self treatment kit!
Thank you for explaining this. I wonder if the FDA’s decision will lead to more at-home transplants. We’ve come so far with C. diff. I pray the FDA proceeds quickly and wisely.
I would hope someone would file suit agst FDA seeking an injunction agst reg which addresses neither food nor drug.
Oh wait, it IS food.
Or was.
Time to barrage the FDA with e-mails and letters that they are preventing us from practicing evidence-based medicine!
Nice article. Actually, I am most concerned that the IND requirement will preclude attempts at treating acutely ill patients with life-threatening C.diff infections with FMT. To my mind, this is the most critical need for urgent study.
I find the FDA’s decision very regrettable.
This is heartbreaking. I am a 19 year old otherwise healthy college student with recurring C diff. (failed vanco.) I had an appointment scheduled for FMT for NEXT WEEK and was really counting on it to take care of C diff. before I study abroad for a year…
Anonymous,
Note that there are at least two sites in Boston (MGH and Lahey) that have an IND approved for FMT.
Paul
A work around is to just perform a simple home enema with saline mixed with the stool of your healthy partner. If desired you can have them tested for disease but I view that as unnecessary since it is my own family and we are certainly aware of our disease states. This is done throughout Europe. The United States is just “ick” conscious. Worked great for us.