October 25th, 2010
Can Barbers Help Fight High Blood Pressure in Black Men?
Larry Husten, PHD
A very long time ago, barbers performed surgical procedures. Now, once again, barbers may have a role to play in the health care of their community.
In the BARBER-1 trial, published in the Archives of Internal Medicine, Ronald Victor and colleagues compared two hypertension monitoring and referral programs based in 17 black-owned barbershops in Texas. Following a 10-week period of baseline blood pressure screening, 8 shops provided standard blood pressure pamphlets to their customers and 9 shops provided blood pressure checks and promoted physician follow-up to their customers. After 10 months, the improvement in hypertension control was significantly higher in the group of customers with actively involved barbers, with an absolute difference between the groups of 8.8%.
In an accompanying commentary, Clyde Yancy considers the trial from a personal perspective “as a black man with [hypertension] who has frequented the same community barber for 17 years.” He notes that hypertension “is both an onerous risk and a scourge for the African American community” and that the BARBER-1 study suggests “a transformative approach that might actually work.” But, he asks, “why must we resort to a community-driven approach that abdicates the responsibility to detect disease and institute preemptive care to well-intentioned, appropriately trained, but nonetheless clinically naive health care providers?” He wonders “why it is they, the barbers, and not we, the physicians, who are providing the care.”
Anything that can improve the health of the people is very welcome news.
Competing interests pertaining specifically to this post, comment, or both:
None
Brilliant study!! Perhaps rational community outreach is the way to reduce coronary mortality, certainly physicians have to date failed. Why have we failed? I am not sure, but we need to think outside the box and the barber shop is one place clearly outside of the medical model box.
If we get churches, barbers, fraternal organizations, employers, fight clubs etc interested in BP screening, we could expand this into true coronary prevention. In addition to defibrillators in the airports, we should have BP checking stations.
There is the concept of “social capital” which is often squandered. The value of my friend being concerned and informed who brings me into the concept of staying healthy is much more powerful than any Public Health Service initiative or AHA advertisement.